It didn’t take long for other members of the Love Island USA season 6 cast including Leah Kateb, Serena Page, Olivia Walker, and Kaylor Martin to speak out against Rodriguez — after fans noticed how they, host Ariana Madix included, collectively unfollowed Rodriguez on Instagram — causing more details about who he really is to come to light.

Craig and Rodriguez confirmed their split on Instagram Tuesday evening, with Craig blasting her now-ex-boyfriend as a “manipulative liar.”