Between those who were voted in initially, selected by the commissioner's office and added as injury/dropout replacements, there are 81 total All-Stars between the National and American Leagues in 2025.

Ohtani and Judge did not participate in the MLB All-Star Game swing-off because they were no longer at the ballpark, according to reports. Both players had pre-arranged plans to leave Truist Park for private flights once they were pulled from the game, an annual trend for many All-Stars who typically have.