Despite Trump’s claims, current NYPD data shows a decline in major crimes across the city. According to figures reported by FOX 5 NY, shootings and gun violence victims have reached all-time lows in 2025. Overall index crimes are down 5% compared to the same period last year, and July marked the tenth consecutive month of declining crime.

The move has already caused confusion among federal agents tasked with tackling local crime. "No one knows who is in charge or what they're supposed to do," one official said.